After four years of hope, government confirms death of 39 Indians in Iraq

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

All 39 Indian construction workers kidnapped by the Islamic State in 2014 from Iraq's city of Mosul have been killed, the government said on Tuesday, confirming the worst fears after keeping alive hopes over their survival for the last nearly four years.

The confirmation came in the form of a suo motu statement External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj made in the Rajya Sabha after a limited truce was struck between the government and the opposition in the chamber of the House Chairman M. Venkaiah Naidu.

Sushma Swaraj, who had earlier made statements, including a July 22, 2017 answer in the Lok Sabha that "as per the latest information from multiple third party sources, they are all safe", on Tuesday rejected the lone survivor Harjit Masih's claim that the 39 Indians were shot dead as a "cock and bull story which wasn't true".

After questions were raised over the government's confirmation, the minister held a press conference to say that the government cannot declare any person dead without concrete proof and it was her duty to inform Parliament first about their death rather than tell their families first.

"I refused to close the files (of the 39 Indians) till we had concrete proof in hand (about their death)," she said.

Earlier, she informed the Rajya Sabha that Indian efforts to search for the missing led to a mound near Badush village in Mosul where a local resident said some bodies had been buried by the Islamic State under a mound.

She said deep penetration radars helped find 39 bodies buried under the mound. The bodies were exhumed and DNA samples from relatives of the missing workers were sent to Iraq.

The minister said DNA samples matched with 38 bodies and the 39th was yet to be fully confirmed because the DNA sample sent was from someone else in his family as his parents are dead.

"The first sign was that the bodies were exactly 39, plus strands of long hair and a 'kada' were also found. So we started conducting DNA tests."

The victims -- 27 from Punjab, four from Himachal Pradesh and six from Bihar and two from West Bengal -- were construction workers employed by an Iraqi company in Mosul. The victims were taken hostage when the Islamic State took control of the second largest city in Iraq. They were trying to leave Mosul when they were abducted.

She said Minister of State for External Affairs V.K. Singh will go to Iraq to bring back the mortal remains of the Indians. "The plane carrying the bodies will first reach Amritsar, then Patna and then go to Kolkata."

She dismissed the claims of Masih, the only survivor who escaped from Mosul. "He was not willing to tell me how he escaped," she said.

He had escaped along with Bangladeshis with the help of a caterer with a fake name Ali, she said.

Briefing media persons later, Sushma Swaraj said her government did not believe in declaring a missing person as believed to be killed.

"Not a single day was spared in our efforts to trace them after they went missing in June 2014," Sushma Swaraj said.

Asked why then there was such a delay in confirming the death of these Indians, she said the DNA samples were initially matched with the bodies found in mass graves in Iraq.

Asked what kept hopes alive of the fate of these men, the minister said at least two Heads of State had said they might not have been killed.

The lone Indian wondered why the government didn't believe him all these years after having "spoken the truth".

"I had been saying for the past three years that all 39 Indians had been killed by ISIS militants," Masih, 28, a resident of a village in Gurdaspur district, told reporters.

He said they all were killed in front of his eyes.

Narrating the incident, Masih said the Indians were kidnapped by the militants and after some days they fired indiscriminately at them.

"I was fortunate to manage to escape from the clutches of the militants despite getting a bullet injury," he said.

Reacting to the confirmation of deaths, Swaran Singh, whose kin was among the 39 dead, said Sushma Swaraj should have informed the aggrieved families about the deaths before "exploding the bomb on us" in Parliament.

"This is nothing less than brutality to the families who were waiting for the safe return of their boys. The minister should have called us before exploding the bomb on us," Singh said.

He said the government earlier trusted unreliable sources about their safety and "it is very much possible that the claim made by them now is also wrong".

Kanwaljit Kaur, mother of Dharmendra Kumar of Batala village in Gurdaspur district, said: "I have not lost hope. I have shortlisted a few girls for him and anxiously waiting to see him as a bridegroom."

Congress leader and Rajya Sabha member Partap Singh Bajwa, who had raised the issue last year in parliament, accused the government of misleading the families.

"This is complete failure of MEA and the government of India," he tweeted. "I raised this issue many a times in Rajya Sabha that why is the Government playing with emotions of families by giving them false hopes. Can there be anything more shameful than this?"

Express your comment on this article

Thursday, March 22, 2018
Very Sad News... Mrs. Sushma Swaraj did her best.

Thursday, March 22, 2018
here we can see how our so called government make peoples fool with their lies.

Please read the words from Marjith the only survivor from Iraq..
He also alleged that he was promised a government job for keeping mum. “But, as I opened by mouth, I was implicated in a fake case and sent to jail for six months. My father died during this period. Even now, intelligence agencies visit me regularly,

shame on dirty politics from BJP

Wednesday, March 21, 2018
Harjith the only one guy who was escaped.. and he try to tell the truth to society that the other 39 was killed in front of him,, and he escaped by telling them that I am from Bangladesh.

do you know what so called Indian government did !!

ask him to shut his mouth,, and spread the lies

and they punished him and put this guy in jail because he was trying to say the truth.

This is the great government , shame shame

Jai ho

Wednesday, March 21, 2018
Modi govt created mess..bfr they giving hope and finally they goofed -up's...If this happened in other country they take harsh action..but unfortunately we are living in a era of wrong governance..

Bajrangi Bhai
Wednesday, March 21, 2018
t's very bad news. Shame on Shushma Swaraj for the lie. Full sympathy with families of those killed.
Philippines government is much stronger than ours.

Shabbir Ansari
Wednesday, March 21, 2018
All politics

Shakeer Ahamad
Tuesday, March 20, 2018
It's very bad news

Submit your comments...
Disclaimer: The views expressed here are strictly personal and does not hold any responsibility on them. We shall endeavour to upload/publish as many of the comments that are submitted as possible within a reasonable span of time, but we do not guarantee that all comments that are submitted will be uploaded/published. Messages that harass, abuse or threaten other members; have obscene, unlawful, defamatory, libellous, hateful, or otherwise objectionable content; or have spam, commercial or advertising content or links are liable to be removed by the editors. We also reserve the right to edit the comments that do get published. Please do not post any private information unless you want it to be available publicly.

Community News presents a Free Seminar on "Dream Merchant" on Thursday, 17th January 2018. This life changing seminar w...

Kuwait Odisha Association -(KOA), organized a Beach Cleanup Drive on 4th January 2019 at Mahboula Beach. Around 100 member...

The Kuwait Wayanad Association (KWA) organized a winter camp at Wafra Farm House as "Vayalnadin Sangam 2019". Started on ...

Advaitham Kuwait Office bearers for the year 2019-20 have been elected unanimously in the 5th Annual General Body meeting he... presents a Free Art Workshop with the theme "Learn to paint your Imagination" On January 18th Friday fro...